Nintendo's Emio Reveal Disappoints Some, But the Famicom Detective Club Sequel Looks to Deliver a Masterful Murder Thriller

The previously hinted “Emio, the Smiling Man” mystery has been revealed as the newest title in Nintendo's once inactive murder mystery visual novel series, Famicom Detective Club, which producer Sakamoto views as the culmination of the whole series.

Emio, the Smiling Man Unveiled as Famicom Detective Club GameFamicom Detective Club Launches New Murder Mystery After Three Decades

The original Famicom Detective Club games, The Missing Heir and The Girl Who Stands Behind, were released in the late 1980s. They let players assume the role of a young man solving murder mysteries in the Japanese countryside. In this new entry, Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club, players will again become assistant detectives, this time at the Utsugi Detective Agency, tasked with solving a series of murders connected to a notorious serial killer known as Emio, the Smiling Man.

As announced by Nintendo on July 17, the game is slated to launch worldwide on August 29, 2024 for the Nintendo Switch and marks the first new Famicom Detective Club story in 35 years. It was hinted at the previous week via a cryptic trailer that showed a mysterious man wearing a trenchcoat and a paper bag over his head that had a smiley face drawn on.

"In Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club, a student has been found dead in a chilling manner, his head covered with a paper bag with a disturbing smiling face drawn on it," the latest installment's synopsis states. "This unsettling image bears a striking resemblance to a recurring clue in a string of unsolved murders from 18 years ago, as well as Emio (the Smiling Man), a killer of urban legend who is said to grant his victims ‘a smile that will last forever.’"

In this game, you must investigate the events that led to the murder of junior high school student, Eisuke Sasaki, where clues relate to unsolved cases from the past. Interview the victim's classmates and associates to gather leads, and examine crime scenes and relevant locations for clues.

Assisting you in the pursuit of truth regarding Emio, the Smiling Man, is Ayumi Tachibana, a fellow detective renowned for her exceptional interrogation skills. Ayumi is a recurring character in the series, introduced in the first game. Leading your unit is Shunsuke Utsugi, the detective agency director, who worked on the same unsolved murders eighteen years prior. Shunsuke appears in the series' second installment and takes the game's orphaned protagonist as his assistant.

Fans Polarized Over Announcement

When Emio, the Smiling Man, was cryptically revealed by Nintendo, it quickly gained traction and interest within the gaming community, perceived as a distinctly different type of Nintendo game. Unlike the company's typically cheerful games, this smiling man was anything but joyful.

Amidst speculation, a Twitter (X) user impressively predicted the teaser's meaning. "Insane theory: Emio is actually the antagonist of a new, darker 3rd Famicom Detective Club game, a follow-up to the first two games' Switch remakes," the fan wrote.

This seemed plausible, and they were correct. While many Famicom Detective Club fans celebrated the revival of their beloved murder mystery point-and-click game, others were less enthusiastic.

Some players disliked the new installment, expressing their disinterest in a visual novel on social media. One user humorously suggested some Nintendo fans were disappointed and angry at the reading involved. Another player replied that these fans "probably hoped Emio would be a different genre, like action horror or something."

Famicom Detective Club Explores Different Mystery Themes

Series producer and writer Yoshio Sakamoto shared insights, via a recent YouTube video, on the creation of Emio – The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club. Recounting the genesis of the Famicom Detective Club series, Sakamoto said that the first two games, The Missing Heir and The Girl Who Stands Behind, were designed to be experienced like a film that you solve yourself.

The Famicom Detective Club series has been lauded for its captivating narratives and atmospheric storytelling. The original games, which were remastered for the Nintendo Switch in 2021, have had a lasting effect on fans. Inspired by the positive reception to these remasters, Sakamoto felt driven to create a brand-new installment in the series. "I knew we'd be able to make something excellent. So, I decided to do it," he stated in the video.

According to an old interview with Wired, Sakamoto drew inspiration from horror filmmaker, Dario Argento, whose use of evocative music and rapid cuts influenced Famicom Detective Club. The Girl Who Stands Behind was inspired by Argento's method of connecting music and visuals used in the murder mystery film Deep Red.

In the same interview, series composer Kenji Yamamoto recalled that he made The Girl Who Stands Behind's final scene as frightening as possible, as Sakamoto had directed him to. The composer used a technique wherein the volume of the game's audio dramatically peaks in the game's final scenes, replicating a kind of jump scare with the startling audio shift.

Emio, the Smiling Man, is an urban legend crafted solely for the new Famicom Detective Club game. Sakomoto, in a recent YouTube video, stated he wants players to enjoy a vibrant journey rooted in the thrill of uncovering the truth behind an urban legend.

While The Smiling Man centers on the theme of urban legends—often eerie tales and rumors of mysterious and perilous events—prior installments in Nintendo’s Famicom Detective Club explored themes of superstitious sayings and ghost stories.

In The Missing Heir, you investigate the mysterious death of Kiku Ayashiro, a member of the affluent Ayashiro family that owns a vast plot of land, passed down through generations, in Myoujin village. The village has a foreboding saying that the deceased will return to kill anyone attempting to steal the Ayashiro family's wealth. You soon uncover a terrifying link between this saying and the serial killings in the game.

Meanwhile, as a budding detective in The Girl Who Stands Behind, you must find the culprit who took the life of an innocent girl, Yoko, and disturbed her high school community. It soon transpires that Yoko was deeply involved in investigating "The Tale of the Girl Who Stands Behind," a ghost story of a bloody girl haunting the school.

A genuine product of intense brainstorming

Speaking in an interview back in 2004, Sakamoto mentioned how he "really enjoyed horror" around the time they were developing the first two Famicom games. "And I also really enjoyed ghost stories about high school," he added. "Because of that, ideas flourished, and I wanted to create a horror story set at an academy."

In multiple interviews, Sakamoto has discussed the unrestricted freedom they had devising ideas for the Famicom Detective Club series. He said that Nintendo provided only the title and let them lead the development. "Whatever it was you devised, they wouldn't say anything," he stated in one interview.

At the time the first two Famicom Detective Club games were initially released in Japan, they received favorable reception from critics. Both Famicom games currently hold a 74/100 Metacritic rating based on critic reviews.

Emio — The Smiling Man is the "pinnacle of everything my most trusted colleagues and I have learned and the concepts we’ve gathered from working on the previous games and their remakes," Sakomoto said. "It’s the product of many profound, creative discussions and efforts with the goal to excel in the screenplay and animations."

Furthermore, it seems that Emio — The Smiling Man will feature a controversial ending that the series producer anticipates will be consistently debated among players "for a long time to come." The game’s script "strikes at the core of what I envisioned from the outset, so the story’s conclusion may be contentious for some players," Sakamoto said.