Home News The Best Murder Mystery Games for a Killer Good Time

The Best Murder Mystery Games for a Killer Good Time

Author : Bella Update : Mar 19,2025

For an unforgettable game night, a murder mystery game is always a winner. Even with the rise of online virtual party games, nothing quite matches the thrill of a physical board game. Murder mystery board games offer a captivating whodunit experience, keeping everyone engaged and guessing until the very end. The best part? There's a huge variety to choose from, whether you're looking for a classic family game like Clue, or a more complex experience for friends, such as One Night Ultimate Werewolf.

TL;DR: The Best Murder Mystery Games

This guide highlights some of our favorite murder mystery games, perfect for your next game night. While geared towards adults, each offers a unique experience suitable for diverse groups. Find the perfect fit for your crew and enjoy! Which ones have you played?

*Additional contributions by Hannah Houlihan*

Clue

Number of players: 2-6

A classic, Clue is a well-known murder mystery game for up to six players. Unravel the mystery of Mr. Boddy's murder at Tudor Mansion—discovering the killer, location, and weapon. A fantastic family game and one of the best family board games available.

One Night Ultimate Werewolf

Number of players: 3-10

A fast-paced, thrilling Werewolf game perfect for large groups. With no moderator, elimination, or downtime, up to ten players can quickly solve the mystery of the Werewolf in a single night. For more party games like this, check out our guide to the best board games for large groups.

Mysterium

Number of players: 2-7

Elevate your murder mystery experience. One player is a ghost guiding psychics (the other players) to identify the killer. Playable with up to seven players, it takes just over 40 minutes to complete.

Exit: The Game – Dead Man on The Orient Express

Number of players: 1-4

An escape room experience at home. Solve the case before the train reaches its destination, channeling your inner Agatha Christie. Note that this game is a one-time play due to the use of case materials.

For similar games, explore our research on other escape room board games.

Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective - The Thames Murders & Other Cases

Number of players: 1-8

Step into the shoes of Sherlock Holmes to solve ten detailed mysteries in Victorian London. This challenging game is best for ages 12+, offering a more complex whodunit experience.

Hunt a Killer – Death at The Dive Bar

Number of players: 1+

For true crime enthusiasts, this immersive puzzle game (1+ players) involves solving the death of bar owner Nick Webster. Expect to spend 45-60 minutes on this case.

University Games Murder Mystery Party Case Files: Underwood Cellars

Number of players: 1+

A more in-depth mystery (2+ hours) where you investigate the death of Napa winemaker Cary Underwood, who disappeared 20 years ago.

Deception: Murder in Hong Kong

Number of players: 4-12

A fast-paced (20 minutes) game where players take on roles like Murderer, Accomplice, and Investigator to narrow down the killer.

13 Dead End Drive

Number of players: 2-4

A classic murder mystery similar to *Knives Out*. Inherit Aunt Agatha's fortune by outsmarting your fellow players.

MicroMacro: Crime City

Number of players: 1-4

Solve 16 cases with a Where's Waldo-esque element. Use the included magnifying glass to investigate details. Playable in 15-45 minutes.

Rear Window

Number of players: 3-5

Based on Hitchcock's film, this game uses image communication to solve a mystery. The director can win by keeping a murder secret, or players win by solving it.